top of page
Untitled_Artwork 3.heic

Ukraine Deep Strikes: The Pentagon Says They Are Not Working, and Berlin Calls That Stupid

3 days ago
7 min read
Project Leaflet stat card: The Deep Strike Split. About 30% of Russian refining capacity hit since late October and 9 of Russia's 35 major refineries disrupted in one week, both per Reuters industry sources; about 50 nations in the Ramstein group, per RFE/RL.
The deep strike split. Stat card: Project Leaflet.

In brief: At the Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting at NATO headquarters on November 17, Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby told Ukraine's backers that Kyiv's long range strikes inside Russia are not ending the war and may be hardening Russian resolve, and urged them to put their money into front line defense instead. Germany's Boris Pistorius called the criticism stupid, and Britain's Wes Streeting said the strikes save lives. The split came hours after Ukraine dropped part of the Crimean Bridge into the Kerch Strait, and two days before the Shenzhen and Berlin summits.

Part of our Ukraine War Analysis coverage.

The Ramstein group exists to fill Ukraine's arsenal, not to argue about how Ukraine uses it. On Tuesday in Brussels it did both. The most senior US defense official in the room used the meeting to question the campaign Kyiv treats as its main source of leverage over Moscow, and the two ministers chairing the meeting answered him in public within hours. It is one of the most open breaks this year between Washington and Ukraine's two largest European backers over how the war should be fought, and it arrives in the same week the United States sits down with Russia and China in Shenzhen.

What Colby Told the Ramstein Group

Elbridge Colby, the US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, spoke at the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels on November 17, according to AP and the Kyiv Independent. RFE/RL describes the group as an informal coalition of some 50 nations, also known as the Ramstein group after the US air base in Germany where it first met.

His core claim, as the Kyiv Independent reported it, was that "such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war." AP reported that he also said the strikes have not blunted Russia's advances on the front. Colby singled out attacks on commercial targets such as the warehouses of Wildberries, one of Russia's biggest online retailers, and said they had probably hardened Russian public resolve and the Kremlin's willingness to escalate. Ukraine says Wildberries goods include equipment used by the Russian military; the company denies it, AP reported.

What Washington wants instead is support for the front line and for midrange strikes on Russian supply lines, which Colby called the most effective way to enable Ukraine's defense, per AP and The Guardian. He praised Ukraine's army as very effective when it fights that way, using drones to slow advances and hit logistics, and he added a caveat reported by both the Kyiv Independent and RFE/RL: Ukraine should not be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back.

He also set expectations low. RFE/RL reported Colby told allies that Moscow is likely to keep fighting at least through the winter, warning that "Russia will continue to generate more manpower" and mobilize its war economy for the long haul.

None of this came from nowhere. President Trump has previously pressed Ukraine to stop hitting Russian oil refineries, blaming them for diesel shortages and rising prices, according to AP and Euronews. And the Kyiv Independent notes that the US has stopped directly funding new weapons for Ukraine under Trump, leaving European allies and Canada to pay, including for US made weapons bought through the PURL program, a point AFP also made.

Berlin and London Push Back

German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius answered first. Per the Kyiv Post, he called it "quite a stupid thing" to condemn strikes on military and military used targets while Russia bombards Ukraine's civilian infrastructure, and said the criticism should be aimed at Russia's nightly attacks on Ukraine's energy, water and heating systems, a point AP and the Guardian also reported.

British Defense Secretary Wes Streeting, who co-chaired the meeting with Pistorius, was just as direct. "It's not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war," he said, per AP. He added that the strikes had helped degrade Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives, according to AP and RFE/RL.

Ukraine's Defense Minister Yevhenii Khmara called Kyiv's operations inside Russia a legitimate response to Moscow's attacks, pointing to Russia's strikes since October and to the attack on the Crimean Bridge, the Kyiv Post reported. AFP and the Kyiv Post both reported that he warned Moscow any further attacks would draw a far heavier response.

President Volodymyr Zelensky, speaking by video link, kept the focus on air defense. He asked backers for Patriot and IRIS-T interceptors from their existing stocks and told Washington, "please do not delay these deliveries," per AFP. Euronews reported he also said Ukraine needs 40 more F-16s. AFP reported that Germany and Norway will fund a new package including Patriot interceptors, with Germany contributing $300 million. The Kyiv Independent framed the whole exchange as a sign of fractures among Ukraine's Western allies, at the moment Europe is taking on more of the bill.

What the Deep Strikes Have Actually Hit

Colby's case is that the strikes are not working. The best independent snapshot of the refinery campaign points the other way, at least on damage done. On November 10, Reuters reported, citing two industry sources, that renewed Ukrainian drone attacks since late October had cut Russia's oil refining capacity by about 30%, as carried by the Kyiv Independent, Ukrinform and Meduza.

The detail behind that number: in a single week, attacks disrupted operations at 9 of Russia's 35 largest refineries, plants with a combined capacity of about 300,000 metric tons a day out of a national total of about 930,000. Russian plants were processing about 700,000 tons a day in late October, and the sources estimated actual processing could fall by up to 200,000 tons a day. Ukrinform added that Rosneft had reinstated fuel sales limits at its filling stations.

Bar chart of Russian oil refining in thousand metric tons per day: 930 primary capacity, 700 processed in late October, 300 capacity at the 9 refineries hit in one week, 200 possible fall in processing. Source: Reuters industry sources, November 10, 2026.
Russian refining in thousand metric tons per day. Source: Reuters, citing two industry sources, Nov 10, 2026, via Kyiv Independent, Ukrinform and Meduza. Chart: Project Leaflet.

Ukraine's General Staff goes further. It says Ukrainian forces have struck all five of Russia's largest refineries since October 30, Omsk, Kirishi, Ryazan, Nizhny Novgorod and Yaroslavl, including a November 11 strike on Omsk, about 2,500 kilometers from the border, according to UNITED24 Media. That is the Ukrainian military's own claim and has not been independently confirmed in full.

The campaign also has a political backstory. Trump announced an energy ceasefire on October 11 that Kyiv disputed, and Zelensky said Ukraine would only stop hitting oil facilities if Russia stopped hitting Ukraine's grid, the Kyiv Independent reported. Russia, meanwhile, keeps exporting diesel under a deal with Trump even as its domestic supply tightens, per Ukrinform and Meduza.

Then there is Kerch. Colby did not address the Crimean Bridge directly, AFP noted, but the strike sits awkwardly with his framing. Oleksandr Danyliuk, president of the Ruta maker Destinus, told Reuters that seven Ruta cruise missiles hit the bridge, as reported by the Guardian. The bridge is a supply line, the very kind of target Colby says Ukraine should hit, but reaching it took a long range campaign. In our reading, the line between deep and midrange strikes is far blurrier in practice than it sounded in Brussels.

The Starshield Problem

The other American lever discussed in Brussels was satellite access. On November 15, Zelensky said restrictions on Ukraine's Starshield system, operated by SpaceX, were hampering drone interception, AP reported via PBS NewsHour. Interceptor drones lose contact with their operators when they fly faster than 161 kilometers per hour (100 miles per hour) near the front and over occupied territory, which leaves them too slow to catch Shahed drones. Zelensky said the limits seemed to come from SpaceX despite assurances from Secretary of State Marco Rubio.

Asked about Starshield in Brussels, Colby declined to comment, per AP. Streeting said allies need consistent and reliable service from Starlink and Starshield, and Khmara said Kyiv was still working with the US to remove the restrictions, according to AP and AFP. The stakes are high: Zelensky said Russia launched more than 2,300 drones, 1,590 guided aerial bombs and 15 missiles in the week before November 15, per AP. Those are Ukrainian figures.

Why It Matters

First, this is a dispute about leverage, not tactics. Long range strikes are the one tool that lets Ukraine impose costs on Russia's economy rather than only absorb Russia's attacks. A Pentagon that calls them ineffective, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in Shenzhen, gives Moscow an argument it has wanted to hear from Washington, whether or not that is the intent.

Second, the burden has shifted. With the US no longer directly funding new weapons for Ukraine, the countries paying the bills are the ones Colby was trying to persuade. Germany and Britain made clear they will not take Washington's view on how Ukraine should spend what they give it, and Germany is putting $300 million into new Patriot interceptors with Norway, per AFP.

Third, the evidence is contested on both sides. The refinery numbers show real physical damage, but Colby's question is whether damage translates into a shorter war, and Russia's continued diesel exports suggest Moscow has room to absorb losses. Neither side's case is settled by the data now public.

What to Watch

In Shenzhen on November 19: whether any readout of the Trump, Putin and Xi meeting mentions Ukrainian strikes inside Russia, or a US request to limit them. In Berlin the same day, where RFE/RL reports Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are expected at the Coalition of the Willing: whether Europe puts new money behind Ukraine's long range production. On Starshield: whether the speed limits on interceptor drones are lifted before the coldest weeks. On the refinery front: whether Russian fuel sales limits spread, and whether Kyiv's strike tempo holds after Brussels. AFP also reported Colby wants a US force review ready for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth by December 1.

Is Colby right that the refinery and retail strikes harden Russia more than they hurt it, or are Pistorius and Streeting right that they buy Ukraine time? Drop your take in the comments.

The channel tracks it daily at t.me/TheLeaflet.

Want this level of analysis in your inbox? Drop your email in the subscribe box at the bottom of this page and the channel will send you the Sitrep Digest: the best of these briefs in a five minute read.

Sources

AP via WKMG (Nov 17, 2026); Kyiv Independent (Nov 18, 2026); Kyiv Independent (Nov 10, 2026); Kyiv Post (Nov 18, 2026); Euronews (Nov 17, 2026); RFE/RL (Nov 17, 2026); AFP via Yahoo News (Nov 17, 2026); The Guardian via AOL (Nov 18, 2026); AP via PBS NewsHour (Nov 15, 2026); Ukrinform (Nov 10, 2026); Meduza (Nov 10, 2026); UNITED24 Media (Nov 12, 2026). Stat card and chart: Project Leaflet.

Comments


bottom of page