Herero and Nama Genocide: The Only Census Counted the Survivors (Cold Files 026)

On 28 May 2025, Namibia marked a Genocide Remembrance Day for the first time. The figures read out that day, and in nearly every account of what Germany did in its colony of South West Africa between 1904 and 1908, are some version of the same sum: about 80,000 Herero before the war, about 65,000 of them dead; about 20,000 Nama, half of them dead.
Part of the Cold Files series.
Only one number in that sum was ever counted, and it was counted after the killing stopped. The order to destroy the Herero survives in the German archive, typed, dated and signed. The death toll does not survive anywhere, because nobody counted the Herero while they were alive. What follows is what the record holds, what it does not, and why the gap has never helped the people who would like to shrink the crime.
The order is a document, not a claim
The Herero rising began on 12 January 1904 with attacks on farms and settlements that killed more than 120 people, according to the German Historical Museum's LeMO history portal. General Lothar von Trotha arrived in June. On 11 August 1904 he attacked the Herero gathered at the Waterberg with about 1,500 troops, by Britannica's count. Most of the Herero, with their families and cattle, broke out east into the Omaheke, the waterless sandveld beyond the plateau.
What followed is described in Mohamed Adhikari's 2008 review of the scholarship in the journal Kronos: a military cordon about 250 km long from Grootfontein to Gobabis, and water holes poisoned, so that people in the desert could neither leave nor drink.
Then came the proclamation. The German History in Documents archive reproduces it from the Bundesarchiv files of the Imperial Colonial Office (RKA 10.01 2089, sheet 23), in David Ciarlo's translation. It declares that the Herero are no longer German subjects and that any Herero found within the colony's borders, with or without a gun or cattle, will be shot. One line needs no gloss: "I spare neither women nor children."
An addendum told troops that shooting at women and children meant firing over their heads. That addendum is a real part of the record, and it is often cited in the order's defence. It sits beside Trotha's own letters. On 27 October 1904, Adhikari's review quotes him writing: "That nation must vanish from the face of the earth."
Even the order's paperwork shows how loosely this history has been handled. The German History in Documents edition, the German Historical Museum and Adhikari all date it to 2 October 1904. Britannica dates it to 3 October and places it at Ozombu Zovindimba. Nobody disputes that it was issued.
Berlin withdrew it, and kept the method
On 23 November 1904 the chief of the General Staff, Alfred von Schlieffen, wrote to Chancellor Bernhard von Bülow about the order; the letter is in the Bundesarchiv, file R 1001/2089, as cited in Lukas Grawe's study in Central European History (published online January 2020). In historian Joël Kotek's translation, Schlieffen accepted that a racial war of this kind could end only in destruction or total submission. Bülow wrote to the Kaiser the next day.
The order was withdrawn in December 1904. The German Historical Museum says the campaign of extermination ended that month after missionaries mediated and Berlin intervened firmly. The exact day depends on which account you read: 6 December in the sources Wikipedia relies on (Häussler 2021, Grawe), 9 December in Britannica.

What replaced the shooting order was captivity. According to the German Historical Museum, Bülow used the word Konzentrationslager officially for the first time on 11 December 1904. Surviving Herero, and from 1905 the Nama who had risen in the south, were put to forced labour in camps at Windhoek, Swakopmund, Lüderitz and elsewhere.
The number nobody counted
Start with the 80,000. The German Historical Museum gives the pre-war Herero population as an estimate of up to 80,000. The Namibian historian Klaus Dierks uses the same figure in his chronology. No source consulted for this file names the person who counted them, because no one did. There was no census of the Herero before the war.
From that estimate, the death toll has been expressed in at least five different ways:
About 80 percent of the Herero, in Adhikari's 2008 review.
About 75 percent, in Britannica.
Between one third and two thirds, in the German Historical Museum's account.
Between 40,000 and 80,000 Herero, the range Wikipedia takes from Lotte Faber-Jonker's 2023 study.
Anywhere from 34,000 to 110,000 Africans across the published literature, a spread Wikipedia's article on the war attributes to authors including Sarkin, Moses and Schaller.

The single figure of 65,000 is the one most readers meet. It appears in Wikipedia's infobox for the war (65,000 to 70,000) and in the 80,000-minus-65,000 framing the same article sources to a 2017 Focus magazine piece. Dierks puts it plainly in his chronology: "absolute evidence of the number of perished Ovaherero and Nama does not exist."
That is the honest position, and it is not a weak one.
The count that does exist
In 1911 the colonial administration counted the African population of the colony. Dierks gives about 15,130 Herero and about 9,781 Nama still alive. The Herero figure also appears, credited to a German census, in a genocide-studies teaching file published by the Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières. Dierks himself flags that the census source is uncertain and needs verifying, and this file found the Nama figure in his chronology only.

The arithmetic is hard to miss. Eighty thousand minus 15,130 is roughly 65,000. A subtraction like that cannot tell the dead from the people who fled across the border, were never registered, or were born after 1904. It can only say that a people estimated at up to 80,000 had become, seven years later, a counted 15,130. That is the shape of the evidence: an estimate on one side, a census on the other, and the war in between.
Where the record is a record
There is one place where Germany did count its dead prisoners. In statistics compiled by the German High Command in 1907, as reported by the historian Casper Erichsen, 7,682 prisoners of war were calculated to have died out of an estimated 17,000. That is a mortality rate of 45.2 percent. Erichsen calls these "mere estimates" and says other official figures were higher.
The breakdown is not settled either. Jeremy Sarkin's 2011 book, as cited by Wikipedia, attributes figures of 7,682 Herero and 2,000 Nama deaths to a report of the Imperial Colonial Office, which would make the official toll larger than the High Command's total.
The worst camp was on Shark Island, off Lüderitz. A military official at the camp estimated that 1,032 of the 1,795 prisoners held there in September 1906 had since died, with 245 surviving, according to Erichsen and David Olusoga's The Kaiser's Holocaust (2010). Adhikari, citing Erichsen's 2005 study, puts the island's death rate at over 70 percent. Germany declared the war over on 31 March 1907. The camps ran into 1908.
These are the hardest numbers in the file because the people who produced them were running the camps.
The book Britain withdrew
Much of what the world first learned came from a British publication. The Report on the Natives of South-West Africa and Their Treatment by Germany, command paper Cd. 9146, was published by HMSO in August 1918. Adhikari's review records that it was compiled in about four months by Major Thomas O'Reilly and A. J. Waters, and that it was meant to influence the terms of the peace settlement.
In 1926, at the urging of the territory's first legislative assembly, the Blue Book was withdrawn from libraries and archives across the British Empire. In South Africa and Namibia, copies were destroyed. Jeremy Silvester and Jan-Bart Gewald reprinted it in 2003.
The best case for the other side
The strongest sceptical argument deserves to be heard in full.
The pre-war population was never counted, so any toll built on it is soft. The Blue Book was wartime propaganda, written by a power that wanted the colony and collected its testimony more than a decade after the events, a caution Reinhart Kössler raised in 2004. The extermination order lasted about ten weeks before Berlin withdrew it. The German forces suffered too: of about 14,000 soldiers shipped out, roughly ten percent died, mostly of disease, the German Historical Museum says. In 1989 the historian Brigitte Lau published "Uncertain Certainties", dismissing the Blue Book and arguing that accounts of the war had denied the Herero any agency of their own.
Germany's own legal position rests on similar ground. Its 2021 declaration recognised the events as genocide "from today's perspective", in what Open Restitution Africa describes as a historical and political, not a legal, sense. Amnesty International reported in October 2025 that Berlin still denies any legal duty to pay reparations.
Each point has an answer in the record. Adhikari notes that Lau's work was seen as apologist because it greatly understated the violence, and that Tilman Dedering's 1993 reply refocused attention on the premeditated destructiveness of German policy. The order does not depend on the Blue Book; it is a German document in a German archive. The camp mortality figures are German too. And the withdrawal of the order did not end the dying; it moved it into the camps. Grawe's study concludes that the General Staff was "complicit in, if not partly responsible for" the genocidal warfare.
What the sceptics have is a real uncertainty about scale. What they do not have is a document that makes the intent go away.
In July 2015 the then foreign minister, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, issued a guideline that the events should be called a war crime and a genocide. On 28 May 2021 Germany announced a joint declaration with Namibia and a payment of about 1.1 billion euros over 30 years for reconstruction and development. Under the deal the money is not called reparations. Open Restitution Africa reports that the agreement remains unratified. In 2023 the Ovaherero Traditional Authority, the Nama Traditional Leaders Association and the Landless People's Movement asked Namibia's High Court to declare it unlawful.
More than a century on, the most precise numbers in this history are still the ones Germany wrote down: one order, one census of the survivors, and a running count of the dead in its own camps. The famous death toll is an estimate standing on another estimate. The crime does not need it to be exact.
What should a museum or a textbook print when the only reliable count is of the survivors? Tell us in the comments.
Sources consulted
German History in Documents and Images: Lothar von Trotha's extermination order, 2 October 1904 (trans. David Ciarlo), from Bundesarchiv RKA 10.01 2089, Bl. 23
Deutsches Historisches Museum, LeMO: Der Herero-Krieg 1904 (Arnulf Scriba, 4 August 2016)
Mohamed Adhikari, "Streams of blood and streams of money", Kronos 34, 2008
Lukas Grawe, "The Prusso-German General Staff and the Herero Genocide", Central European History, published online 10 January 2020
Klaus Dierks, Chronology of Namibian History, entry for 1911
Casper Erichsen, "Namibia's concentration camps", namibweb.com
Casper Erichsen and David Olusoga, The Kaiser's Holocaust, 2010 (as cited by Wikipedia)
Jeremy Sarkin, Germany's Genocide of the Herero, 2011 (as cited by Wikipedia)
Britannica, German-Herero conflict of 1904-07
Report on the Natives of South-West Africa and Their Treatment by Germany, Cd. 9146, HMSO, August 1918
S. Hirsch and S. Moisan, Genocide of the Herero and Nama in Namibia, UQTR teaching file
Open Restitution Africa: Joint Declaration by Germany and Namibia, policy record
Amnesty International: Germany must deliver reparatory justice, 2 October 2025
BBC: Namibia marks colonial genocide for first time with memorial day, 28 May 2025 (as cited by Wikipedia)
Wikipedia: Herero and Nama genocide; Herero and Nama War; Shark Island concentration camp; Battle of Waterberg (for secondary citations only)
More Cold Files: Congo War Death Toll and Algerian Civil War Massacres.
Next in the Cold Files: the Bengal famine of 1943, and the death toll a commission set before anyone had counted.
Cold Files is a twice-weekly deep read from Project Leaflet. For the daily situation reports and every new file, follow The Leaflet on Telegram.
.png)




Comments